Herbsaint Original Recipe
User-Generated Cocktails

Energy Drinks and Alcopops

I enjoyed reading this long article on alcoholic energy drinks, written by Kit Stolz for the Ventura County Reporter.

After reading the long report about the sales, marketing, and consumer base of "alcopops" - caffeinated energy drinks- it seems to me that these are more like modern-day wine coolers, in a modern day world where young people probably consume five times as much caffeine as they did in the 1980's when wine coolers were all the rage. I'm not so sure that people who were sneaking Bartles & James peach coolers in high school should be rallying to ban Rockstar 21.

Here are some really great quotes from the story.

A counselor in San Diego gave a presentation to some teachers at a middle school, and went out at lunchtime and counted 12 students with alcoholic energy drinks. They didn’t need to conceal it because the adults didn’t even know these drinks existed.”

I think this is a very valid argument for better labeling of energy drinks- a big fat government warning sticker "Contains Alcohol" on these drinks wouldn't be such a bad thing, and would help adults and store owners better identify which items contain alcohol and which do not.

Now, about making them illegal entirely:

Under federal law, manufacturers must show that any substance deliberately added to a food or beverage sold in the United States must be “generally recognized as safe” (a standard known as GRAS). Mosher doubts that alcoholic energy drink manufacturers will be able to meet that test.

 “Under FDA rules, manufacturers have to establish before they put additives in any food or beverage that the products are safe,” he said, “But all the scientific studies we have seen say that it’s not safe.”

Mosher points to a study published last year by a doctor at Wake Forest, Mary O’Brien, which showed that college students who consumed alcoholic energy drinks had “a significantly higher prevalence of being taken advantage of sexually, taking advantage of someone else sexually, riding with a drunken driver, or being physically injured,” even in comparison to those who drank alcohol, but without caffeine.

I think this argument is weak and wrong. Separately alcohol and caffeine are regulated and approved, so is adding one to the other an unsafe additive? I think not. Nobody (yet) is advocating banning the combination of Red Bull and Vodka (or the Irish Coffee for that matter) when mixed together from separate containers. Putting them together in one drink seems efficient, if often a bad idea.

This I didn't know:

In a 2007 report for the Marin Institute, he and a co-author revealed that alcoholic energy drinks such as Tilt, Rockstar 21, and Sparks cost about 25 percent less than comparable nonalcoholic energy drinks such as Rockstar Juiced, Lost Energy and SoBe Adrenaline Rush.

But seems to support my existing belief that energy drinks are horrendously overpriced.

I think I am coming to the conclusion that more dramatic warning labels may be needed for alcopops, but I don't support a ban on them. The idea that these products are marketed to "children" I think is off-base. Can you say that extreme sports are marketed to children, or are they an adult activity that's exciting to younger people? Energy drinks in general take their marketing cues from extreme sports (heck, even Gatorade does) and so I think it's not exactly fair to claim that they're going for underage drinkers specifically. Maybe if there was an alcoholic energy drink that was labeled "Extreme Algebra" my opinion would change.

Overall you don't need to tempt underage people to try alcohol; they'll go out of their way to find it for themselves. The reasons for that have nothing to do with the existence of alcopops.

What do other people think? Are alcopops really a problem at all? Should we change the labeling, tax them as spirits (as a lot of legislation proposes), ban them outright?

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jayson Wilde

I think the only problem with these types of drinks are the people that buy or order them. Nothing is more awful to me than a jager bomb or anything with Red Bull....not to mention Sparks or any of those drinks. However, they are good for these things in no particular order: Mixed Martial Arts, Affliction T-Shirts, Lifted Trucks, TapOut, Wakeboarding, House Boats, Striped Shirts that are Screen Printed, White Sunglasses, Drop Shots, The Beach, Fauxhawks and getting "Bitches".

Chip and Andy

Personally, I don't like any of the energy drinks.... with or without alcohol. But those are my tastes, everyone else's differ.

If the alcohol content is comparable to other taxed adult beverages, then they should be taxed similarly. If the ABV is the same as a beer, they should be taxed like beer. If the ABV is the same as wine, tax it like wine and etc....

Now if you'll excuse me I am going to go finish my cup of coffee with a splash of brandy.

mjs013

You are all missing the point that AEDs are like throwing gasoline on a fire...they are fueling an epidemic of youth binge drinking and alcohol-related harm. And if you don't think the producers of these pre-mixed drinks don't appreciate and exploit the fact that over 40% of them are consumed by underage youth, your heads are in the sand.

Camper English

MJS- I don't think we're missing the point at all. Alcohol exists and underage people try to get it, whether it's in energy drink or any other form.

Extreme Sports Blogger

Energy drinks only run parallel to sports and have very little to do with any particular sport and more to do with marketing and reaching an audience primarily consisting of none sports people.

I don’t see sportsmen or women queueing up at the local supermarket or corner shop purchasing these drinks. What I see are generally ordinary people buying it as a refreshment and not as part of any energy boosting benefit or gain.

As someone who participated in multiple extreme sports, many of which are sponsored by large energy drinks companies, I can say quite categorically that I don’t drink any of them and know of very few extreme sports participants who do.

Aside from water and perhaps drinks that are self-prepared with the required glucose and salts etc, most athletes don’t actually tough the branded and heavily marketed stuff.

They may be pictured with it but this has more to do with money than effects.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)