The Bar Agricole Bar Staff
Little Changes in Big Canada

Rum Judgement

Last week I helped judge the Ministry of Rum competition in San Francisco. 

We only had to judge 50 or so rums over the course of two days, so it wasn't nearly as grueling as other judging competitions, but it was still pretty interesting. 

Glasses of rums 

Ed Hamilton, who runs Ministry of Rum and the competition, said a major challenge is deciding on categories of rums to judge. When I write about rum (which is all I seem to be doing this year) I typically divide them into regional and historical categories based on where the rums are produced. 

But at the competition we looked at them in terms of what was in the bottle. Some of the categories we considered were

  • Sugar cane-based spirits (agricole, cachaca, and other rums made from sugar cane instead of molasses)
  • White rums
  • Dark rums (rums without an age statement)
  • Aged rums (rums with an age statement)
  • Premium rums (some of the higher-end aged rums)
  • Flavored rums and spiced rums
  • Overproof rums

Then we could further look at cross-over categories such as aged sugar cane spirits, flavored overproof rums, etc. If we looked at every rum on the market we could come up with a ton of categories. Luckily we weren't judging every rum on the market- only the ones that entered the competition. 

Row of rumss

Judging spirits can be difficult if you have too many- it's hard to be a good judge when you experience palate fatigue. But more importantly it's always a pleasure to challenge what you think a spirit tastes like by doing blind tastings.

In this competition I was surprised to find that I gave low scores to some brands I thought I loved and high scores to brands I had previously ignored. That always happens and it's a good, if embarrassing, thing. 

I also noticed I am oblivious to certain flavors that can seem artificial (including vanilla and chocolate) and I have a high sensitivity to certain other flavors including rose and jalapeno.  I also have a low sensitivity for spirits and cocktails that are too sweet until about the third sip whereas other people react right away. Every blind tasting helps further tune your palate. 

When Hamilton talked about the spirits we'd just judged (after we'd judged them, of course), he'd constantly note how the different brands were changing over time: most of them for the better, I'm happy to report. 

Hamilton often says, "If you haven't tasted every bottle behind your bar in the past six months, you don't know what they taste like." We think of spirits as a constant, but they do change. 

Anyway, after the competition we went out drinking. First we started at Heinhold's First and Last Chance Saloon where Jack London used to hang. 

Heinholds first and last chance saloons 

Then we took a bus to Smuggler's Cove for some flaming tiki drinks. 

Smugglers cove fires
Four torch tiki drinks



Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Matt R.



Camper it was a pleasure sharing this experience with you!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)