Hemingway Goes to Mexico
A Map of the Online Drink and Food World Featuring Alcademics

Better Tools for the Dry Shake

The "dry shake" is a technique that bartenders use to emulsify the egg in egg white drinks to give them a nice foamy head.


Before adding the ice, they put the egg white and other liquid ingredients in a cocktail shaker and give it a good shake. Then they add ice and shake again.

Many bartenders also put a spring into the shaker with the liquids to help the dry shake along. This spring is taken off a Hawthorn strainer and used. This is a pain in the butt though.  

Audrey Saunders (owner of New York's Pegu Club), speaking at a seminar at Tales of the Cocktail, mentioned in passing a different tool to use instead of the Hawthorn strainer spring: a cat toy. 


Cat toy2


I haven't tried it myself, but it seems there are a lot of good options out there. Some are rubber balls (would a gumball machine SuperBall work?), some are whisk-like... 


And some are even shaped like springs.


Cat toy1


Have you used these? Anything else? 


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


I have used the hawthorne spring method, and agree that it is a pain in the butt. I have seen bartenders at Rob Roy in Seattle use the ball-shaped spring from a whisk sectioned from its handle in the dry shake as well.

Camper English

I saw someone with a round spring-ball thing once that looked perfect. I wish I could remember who it was.

Doug Winship

My wife found me a plastic shaker for making smoothies or something. Threw away the shaker, but guard carefully the two-inch ball whisk that came inside. Fits much better than the Hawthorne spring, dishwasher safe, and easy to handle.

And no, I don't know where she got it either!

Camper English

Aha! I looked up "Ball Whisk" on Amazon and found what you're talking about.

Camper English

And that's the same spring-ball I was talking about above. Now to find a supply of them in bulk...


If you make a Clover Leaf with Catnip instead of mint, what do you call it?

I like to use a spring for whipping cream, but haven't noticed it makes a significant difference for egg whites.

Shaking egg white drinks with a single large cube of ice instead of small cubes seems to make a bigger difference and is much less of a pain in the butt.

Prince of Cups

I use the spring-ball from the Blender Bottle.


Personally I don't use anything at all. I've tried everything from dry shaking for several minutes to pre-blending. Honestly, the difference is as near as makes no difference. I don't bother with any special tools or techniques any more.

Aside from the dry shake, sometimes I use Chris McMillian's Ramos technique where one uses little ice and shakes until the ice has all been crushed/melted.


also another technique passed down from the bartenders at Cure is to dry shake with no sugar first... then add sugar and wet shake... supposedly, the reaction between the acid and egg white creates a stiffer foam without the sugar there to get in the way... may be an interesting thing to test... I've noticed a difference, but I still think the freshness of egg white still makes the biggest effect...


i agree... those blender bottle balls work really well.

Liberty Bar

AGS - I agree. It also so much depends on the eggs. I sometimes will have eggs that foam up beautifully, then go to the store to grab some eggs and use my same methodology (dry-shake with the spring from a cheap Hawthorn strainer), and it'll be flat.

To get around this problem and have 100% great foam, I have taken a REALLY demanding production of shaking the eggs in one tin, and then the mixture in the other and then combining them at the last minute with ice. What a pain in the ol' neck, but it works pretty much all the time perfectly. Or, you can just use the hand whisker...

Oh! Bitters. Most bitters will break down egg white in a moment. I wonder what part of what's in the bitters that affects the foaming, but that bums me out when I have a flat drink.

I may try the cat toys at Liberty just to see the expressions from my customers.

Camper English

Especially if you use the cat toys with the bell in the middle.

Remco Babay

What seems to work best for me is just 'dry shaking' it with 1 ice cube. After that just shake it vigorously with the entire shaker filled with ice. Clover Club and Sours haven never looked that great!

Blair Frodelius

What size egg do most of you use? Small, Medium, Large or Extra Large? It seems that you don't want a lot of white, otherwise the drink is too "eggy".

Camper English

In many bars now I see bartenders using egg whites in a maple syrup dispenser so they can use just 1/4 - 1/2 ounce or so. At home I tend to use just part of a medium egg white.

Prince of Cups

Someplace I read (Blumenthal, maybe) that an egg white has enough proteins to hold several times its own volume of water in foam, the order of 15-20x, it is just a matter of the time taken to whip air into the mixture.

With separated egg whites (separated and strained prior to the beginning the shift), I see about a 1/2oz measure. I don't know if anyone's prep calls for pre-watering the egg whites or for varying the amount based on the other ingredients in the cocktail.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)